
I Sold You Shortcuts. A Shortcut Is Just a Long Way With Better Packaging.
Case: The People v. "Stack the Supplements."
The Charge
The Body Building, Nutrition Corner and Project Fitness sections of this blog have their share of this. Powders, pills, drinks, timings, and an aura of insider knowledge.
The Prosecutor has brought a shaker bottle the size of a small child and would like to enter it into evidence. The Skeptic has asked what's in it. He says "proprietary blend." She says that's the first thing she'd like to cross-examine. Court is in session.
The Cross-Examination
Let's talk about how supplements get sold. There's a gleaming tub. There's a man with an absurd jaw. There's a promise that the thing inside will do what years of boring consistency couldn't.
And here's what I've noticed after watching this for years: the more confident the packaging, the smaller the effect. The things that work don't need a flaming font. They sit in plain tubs, they're a bit dull, and nobody makes a movie trailer about them.
A shortcut is just a long way with better packaging. The destination is the same: sleep, food, training, time. The supplement industry sells the packaging.
Original Idea #1: The Packaging Premium
Kong's Packaging Premium
The price of a supplement is mostly the price of the story. Ask what you're paying for: the ingredient, or the label, the influencer and the flavour called "Atomic Cookie Rage"?
A useful test: look at the ingredient list and imagine it with the label stripped off. Plain description, plain price. If it still looks like a bargain, great. If the magic leaves with the branding, you've been paying a premium for a feeling.
Original Idea #2: The Cake and the Sprinkles
I picture training and nutrition as a cake. The cake is the boring stuff: sleep, enough food, enough protein, a training programme you actually follow, and time. The sprinkles are supplements.
Most people are obsessing over sprinkles while they haven't baked the cake. They're asking which powder to buy while sleeping five hours a night and skipping meals. No sprinkle in the world saves a missing cake. And once the cake is baked well, the sprinkles are a small, optional extra, which is exactly what they should be.
Original Idea #3: The Rounding Error Test
Before I buy any supplement, I ask one rude question: is the effect bigger than the rounding error of one good night's sleep?
If a product claims to improve my recovery by "up to" a small percentage, and a single extra hour of sleep does far more, then I should be buying the hour of sleep. It's cheaper, it has no flavour options, and it doesn't come in a tub. (This is my sanity check, not a measured comparison. But it points the right way almost every time.)
Original Idea #4: Placebo Honesty
Here's an uncomfortable one. Some of what supplements "do" is placebo: the effect of expecting to feel better. Placebo effects are real, and not worthless. But you shouldn't pay supplement prices for something a belief could deliver for free.
What I'd like to see is Placebo Honesty: being clear with yourself about whether something works because of the ingredient or because of the ritual. If it's the ritual, that's fine. A cup of tea before a session is a lovely ritual and costs very little. Just don't tell yourself the tea is pharmacology.
Original Idea #5: The Boring Shortlist, and Who Tests It
If you do want to use a supplement, my approach is to treat it like hiring someone. Look at the track record, not the pitch. The ones with the strongest research tend to be the dull, long-studied ones. The ones with the best marketing tend to be the opposite.
And check who's testing the product. Supplements aren't regulated like medicines in many places, and contamination and mislabelling are known problems. If you compete in a drug-tested sport, athletes are generally advised to use products that have been independently batch-tested. Check your own country's rules, and talk to a doctor or dietitian before you add anything, particularly if you take medication or have a health condition.
What the Evidence Says
The Skeptic takes the stand. She's brought the ingredient list. The Prosecutor's shaker has fourteen items on it, and she'd like to read them out slowly.
A few supplements have solid evidence, and they're boring. The International Society of Sports Nutrition's position stand on creatine (Kreider et al., 2017) concluded that creatine monohydrate is an effective and generally safe supplement for improving high-intensity exercise performance in healthy people. It's a long-studied, unglamorous product with a decent track record. That doesn't mean it's right for everyone, and it's not a recommendation. It's an example of what "boring, well-studied" looks like.
Placebo effects are real and can be strange. In a small trial, Kaptchuk and colleagues (2010) gave people with irritable bowel syndrome a placebo and told them honestly it was a placebo, and they still reported improvements compared with no treatment. It's a small study and it doesn't mean placebos fix everything. It means expectation and ritual are powerful, which is why marketing works.
Marketing outruns evidence. The wider point, which I'm stating in general terms and not as a specific finding, is that product claims in this industry often go beyond what research supports. When a label sounds like a miracle, that's the moment to lower your expectations and raise your standards.
"Everyone serious is on something." Plenty of serious people are on sleep, food and patience.
"Supplements help." A few well-studied ones may help a little, at the margins, once the cake is baked.
"Fuel properly." Absolutely. Real food, enough of it, at sensible times, does most of the job.
The Sentence: What I Do Now
- Bake the cake first. Sleep, food, protein, training and time before anything in a tub.
- Run the Rounding Error Test. If an extra hour of sleep beats it, I buy the hour.
- Strip the label. What would this cost without the story?
- Prefer the boring and well-studied over the new and exciting.
- Check who tests it, and check with a doctor or dietitian before adding anything.
- Practise Placebo Honesty. Enjoy the ritual, but don't mistake it for chemistry.
Homework
This week, do a Cupboard Audit. Line up every supplement, powder and tub you own. For each, write down what you bought it for, what evidence you have that it's working (be honest), and what it cost. Then check your sleep, protein and meals for the same week and ask which of the two lists is further from where it should be. If the tubs are winning, you've found your cake problem. Report back, and don't be alarmed if the shaker bottle is the least useful thing on the list.
The Prosecutor says he'd like to withdraw his shaker bottle. The Skeptic says he can withdraw it as soon as he's explained "proprietary blend," and that she'll wait.
Straighten your spine. Leave the crown crooked.
No hype. Just what holds up.
House of Kong ♔ · The Crooked Crown
General information only, not medical or dietetic advice, and not a recommendation to take any product. Please speak to a doctor, dietitian or pharmacist before using supplements, especially if you have a health condition, are pregnant, or take medication. Sources: Kreider et al. (2017), Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition (creatine position stand); Kaptchuk et al. (2010), PLoS ONE (open-label placebo in IBS; small trial). The Packaging Premium, the Cake and the Sprinkles, the Rounding Error Test and Placebo Honesty are the author's own opinions and frameworks, not research findings.